Supreme Seafood Restaurant - North Branford, Connecticut

Casey G.

I had a fantastic experience eating at Supreme Seafood last week. I tried a bunch of different dishes and they all did not disappoint! The surf and turf burger was phenomenal and the Caesar salad topped with lobster is my new favorite dish. Everything tasted so fresh and delicious. The staff was very attentive and kind, making my experience a 10/10. I will definitely be back again!

Bill X.

Supreme Seafood remains one of my favorite quick serve seafood restaurants. Staff is friendly and service is great.
Although Supreme Seafood focuses on seafood, they also serve great hot dogs, burgers, grilled chicken and a variety of side dishes.
The 5-ounce lobster roll was excellent and a relative bargain at $26. If you order it as a platter for an extra $5 you get a side dish and a very generous portion of French fried. I special ordered the lobster roll with the butter on the side and cold lobster inside of a toasted Apicella buttered roll and received exactly what I ordered. A signature butter sauce containing lemon juice is available. The lobster bisque and New England clam chowder are also excellent.
The restaurant was busy with almost every table occupied but there is also outdoor seating.

This is a very small place in a strip mall but the food was absolutely incredible and the portions very generous. If you’d like fried clams, you won’t find a better place. Service was quick, and the staff was helpful and friendly.
Based on my latest visit, the food is still great. Prices are higher for food everywhere but at least the portions are generous. If you want a particular dish, perhaps call ahead to see if it is available since on my latest visit, they were out of fried calm strips and scallops, which seems a little odd. Love the coleslaw and the lobster roll at $50 which contains a half pound of lobster and is served hot. French fries come in a generous portion, enough for 2 or 3 people. I don't recommend the crab cake which was a bit mushy and inferior to what you can buy frozen in the supermarket. The lobster bisque was excellent with a generous portion of lobster meat.

Food O. C.

One visit to Supreme Seafood and they very much have our hearts! Not only was all of the food delicious, but their portion sizes are impressive! We still can’t get over the size of their “smallest” lobster roll - I can tell you they didn’t skimp out and it had nice chunks of claw meat! Another one of my favorites was the calamari supreme, which is made with their homemade marinara sauce and was truly addicting. Every week they do a special with a fresh catch called “Off the Hook”. It was mahi mahi when we went, and it was fantastic! So many options for land lovers too. Great wings, and the chicken parm sandwich was a showstopper with that big slab of fried mozz! A great casual spot with friendly staff. We’ll definitely be coming back when we’re in the area!

Patricia O.

Food insanely good 👍- broccoli rabe with sausage a MUST try. The lobster roll 5oz perfect for one🫣

N L.

Amazing food and service. I can still imagine the taste of those fresh oysters and scallops as I am writing this review. One of the best fried seafood places on the shoreline!

brandon M.

Best lobster roll in ct hands down no questions about it. Packed a nice bite with plenty of whole. Yea I said it whole lobster claws. Bun was fantastic held together with that 8 ounces of buttery lobster gussy. I digress, wait staff was top notch and we had our rolls within 13 minutes. I mean come on how to you beat that. My one gripe is price, however I’m willing to pay it for the quality and quantity I received. I mean come on it was a bunch of lunch with a bite like no other! I will be back.

Albert ?. O. R.

First off, if you’re going to get a seafood combo, stick to the half orders instead of the full orders. I got the full, my friend got the half and it was practically the same amount of food. Fries and onion rings are not included, overpriced and overcooked. Scallops were overcooked and chewy. Whole bellies were small, overcooked and rubbery. Came with a TON of calamari rings for some reason. Fries and onion rings weren’t good (but they never are at any seafood joint I’ve ever gone to). The one upside was it came with a lot of good sized shrimp. No offense to anyone who likes this place but I’ll probably never go back. Lenny’s Indian head is closer, a lot better AND cheaper. Whole belly seafood combo with a fountain soda and a half & half order of fries and onion rings was $70 after taxes and tip. That’s just crazy.

Since google won’t let me reply to their reply, I’ll just do it here: I went to your establishment because a friend of mine claimed it was SOOOOO good, that he had to go there twice in basically one week. He claimed that you had the best onion rings he’d ever had. Don’t worry, they weren’t to me and I will definitely never take this guy’s advice on food places ever again. I took one bite and didn’t touch the rest, just like I didn’t touch most of the food I got from you except the shrimp. But just because I’m not the biggest fan of onions, it doesn’t mean other people in my life aren’t so I brought everything I didn’t eat home for others. Just because that’s my name, doesn’t mean I’m not willing to give things a try. I could say the same thing about you: your name doesn’t make sense….supreme seafood? But you’re subpar at best….. tell you what: I’ll change my name if you change yours. 🙂

thedarkhorse100

I love this place. I get the supreme combo I’m guessing at the name. It comes with everything. Two pieces of fish with clams shrimp and calamari. I don’t believe I’m missing anything. The Lobster rolls are great. I’ve never had a disappointing meal here. The girl that’s been there forever is always pleasant and has gorgeous thick black hair lol. That’s my personal review lol. But two thumbs up , I’m going tonight and that’s why I’m on the page . Go here you’ll love it